Same Violation, Different Rulebook: New GCheck Report Finds Workplace Rules Bend Nearly Twice as Often for Top Performers

The Performance Privilege, a randomized experiment with 2,000 US workers, finds managers investigate and discipline at the same rate, then split at one decision: whether to grant an exception


LOS ANGELES, Nov. 16, 2026 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- When a top performer and a typical performer are each confirmed to have knowingly submitted the same expense claim twice, managers investigate and discipline both at close to the same rate, according to The Performance Privilege, a new study from GCheck, a modern, compliance-first hire-to-retire screening platform and FCRA-regulated consumer reporting agency (CRA). The difference shows up in one decision: whether to set the rule aside. In a quality-screened sample, 49% of managers would grant a policy exception to a confirmed violation by a top performer, compared with 27% for a typical performer doing the same thing. That makes a top performer about 1.8 times as likely to receive one. Each manager judged only one version of the case, so any difference between versions traces back to how the employee was described.

GCheck calls this the performance privilege: the tendency for an employee’s performance level to shift how a manager interprets and responds to identical conduct. It describes a pattern across many decisions and carries no judgment about any individual manager or employee.

“Managers investigate their top performers as carefully as anyone else,” said Houman Akhavan, Founder and CEO of GCheck. “Where they differ is the next step: whether to waive the rule for this person, this time. That decision needs a paper trail, a written reason for every exception, not just the ones somebody happens to question.”

Investigated Equally. Excused Unequally.

Investigation and discipline barely moved with the employee’s performance. About 95% to 96% of managers said they would investigate a confirmed violation, and roughly two in three recommended formal action, whoever the employee was. The evenness stops at the exception: across all manager responses, 44% would grant one to a top performer, compared with 33% for a typical performer doing the same thing. The same asymmetry showed up earlier, before the facts were even settled. When it was unclear whether the duplicate expense was a mistake or intentional, 37% of managers said an honest mistake was very likely for a top performer, against 24% for a typical one, even though most managers extended good faith either way (77% versus 74%).

No Extra Punishment for the Strugglers

The study also tested whether the same rule lands harder on a struggling employee. It does not. Managers recommended formal action for 70% of low performers, about the same as 68% for typical performers, and supported an exception for 29%, close to the 33% for a typical performer. What changed was the explanation. Among managers deciding a low performer’s case, 41% pointed to the employee’s performance history or a broader pattern, against 24% who pointed to the seriousness of the incident itself, even though the outcome they recommended matched a typical performer’s. The study specified this comparison before fielding and reports the result as found: top performers receive a premium, and no one else receives a penalty.

Managers Trust Their Stars. They Do Not Watch Them Less.

Managers trust their highest-performing employee’s judgment far more than their lowest performer’s, 83% versus 32%. Day-to-day oversight does not follow that slope: review rates stay close for every employee, from 69% to 77%, and more managers review their top performer’s work more closely than less closely (36% versus 22%). It is that trust, more than any difference in supervision, that a manager carries into an ambiguous case.

Workers Report It. They Just Doubt It Will Count.

Workers do not hold back when a top performer is involved: 65% said they would report or raise a duplicate expense with a manager, and willingness did not drop for a top performer. But confidence in the outcome splits along the same line as the exception itself. After a confirmed violation, 72% of workers reading about a typical performer expected management to act the same way regardless of the coworker’s performance, compared with 62% of those reading about a top performer. Unreported problems are already the norm: the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission found that roughly three in four people who experience workplace harassment never report it, most often out of fear of disbelief, inaction or retaliation (EEOC, 2016). A coworker who doubts the outcome has one more reason to stay quiet next time.

Consistency, Not Surveillance

Asked what would most help ensure employees are treated consistently regardless of performance, 57% of respondents pointed to clear written criteria applied the same way to everyone, 52% wanted a safe way to raise concerns about inconsistent treatment, 45% wanted manager training on separating trust from accountability, and 44% wanted documentation required for any exception, lenient or harsh. Managers lean toward training and documentation, and non-managers lean toward a safe channel and leadership modeling the standard. None of it asks for softer rules, and none of it asks for closer monitoring.

The findings carry practical weight beyond the survey. An exception granted without a written reason leaves a weaker record behind the next decision involving the same conduct. Documenting the reason, every time, is what keeps that comparison defensible if it is ever challenged.

“Employees want one rulebook, applied the same way regardless of who’s in the room,” said Akhavan. “Getting there starts with writing down the reason for every exception, including the ones nobody questions.”

GCheck surveyed 2,000 employed US adults on Pollfish on November 5, 2026, including 893 people managers and 1,107 workers without direct reports, weighted by age, gender and region. Each respondent was randomly assigned one of five versions of the same duplicate-expense scenario, varying only whether the violation was confirmed and whether the employee was described as a top, typical or low performer. The quality-screened sample sets aside responses flagged for speeding, identical answers across a grid or a failed comprehension check, and retains 524 of the 893 managers. Figures describe stated intentions in a hypothetical scenario and are rounded to the nearest whole percent.

Read the full findings from The Performance Privilege and explore the latest GCheck news and updates here.

About GCheck

GCheck is a modern, hire-to-retire screening platform dedicated to Compliance for Good®, helping organizations hire and retain with speed, accuracy, and fairness. We operate across the entire employee lifecycle, delivering background checks, identity verification, drug testing, employment and professional verifications, continuous monitoring, and compliance management through one unified platform.

Our Compliance for Good® framework is built on three pillars: transparent compliance, fair compliance, and protective compliance, ensuring every screening decision upholds dignity, reduces risk, and strengthens trust. GCheck serves enterprise HR teams, healthcare organizations, nonprofits, and regulated industries that need more than a fast check; they need a compliant, ethical, and audit-ready screening partner.

To learn more, visit gcheck.com.

Media Contact
GCheck Media
press@gcheck.com


GlobeNewswire